PRETORIA, Gauteng — Motorists are facing a massive RTIA refund process after the Road Traffic Infringement Agency admitted to unlawfully collecting R14.2 million in AARTO traffic fines during the 2025/26 financial year.
According to the agency’s annual report for the year ending 31 March 2026, a critical finding was identified regarding infringement items that were collected but never properly served in accordance with the Administrative Adjudication of Road Traffic Offences (AARTO) Act.
Advocate Stefanie Fick from the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (OUTA) explained that the RTIA failed to follow its own legislated procedures. Under the AARTO Act, a strict sequence must be followed: an infringement notice must be served, followed by a courtesy letter within 32 days, and finally an enforcement order. The R14.2 million in refunds indicates that the agency collected payments—often at the courtesy letter stage—without properly serving the initial infringement notices to motorists.
Fick expressed concern over the procedural failures, questioning the reliability of the RTIA as it prepares to expand the system nationwide.
The unlawful collections and subsequent refunds only apply to motorists in Johannesburg and Tshwane, as these are the only municipalities where the AARTO system has been piloted thus far.
Determining eligibility for the refunds, however, presents a massive administrative challenge. Fick noted that with millions of tickets issued monthly in these pilot regions, manually processing individual refund claims would be an administrative nightmare. She suggested that a more practical solution might be to issue credit notices linked to motorists’ national identity numbers, which could be deducted from future fines. However, she acknowledged that individual motorists who paid for specific, unlawfully processed contraventions may still demand direct cash refunds.
Beyond the immediate financial fallout, OUTA continues to raise concerns about the broader efficacy of the AARTO system in improving road safety. Fick pointed out that the original legislation dates back to 1998, yet it took a decade to implement in the initial pilot cities. Now in 2026, as the system rolls out to additional municipalities, historical inefficiencies remain a concern.
Fick emphasized that the AARTO system alone cannot resolve the country’s severe road carnage. True road safety requires a combination of functional law enforcement and visible policing to catch severe offenders, alongside addressing systemic issues such as corruption, deteriorating road conditions, and unroadworthy vehicles. Without these foundational elements, she argued, the infringement agency’s administrative efforts will not translate into safer roads.
Â