The Free State High Court is set to deliver a crucial judgment in the trial-within-a-trial involving Moroadi Cholota, Accused 17 in the R255 million asbestos roof removal corruption case. Judge Phillip Loubser will determine whether her extradition from the United States was lawful, a challenge that has delayed the main trial.
Cholota, a former assistant to disgraced ex-Free State Premier Ace Magashule, claims the state’s extradition process was flawed. Her legal team argued that critical evidence was omitted, which could have rendered the application unsuccessful. They also alleged that investigators intimidated her during a two-day interview in the U.S.
“The state did not present any relevant evidence on the legality of Cholota’s extradition,” her lawyer contended, accusing officials of failing to call key witnesses.
In response, the state maintained that due process was followed, calling two witnesses who testified that Cholota was informed of her rights. Prosecutors argued that the U.S. Department of Justice, known for its stringent standards, would not have approved the extradition without sufficient evidence.
Cholota’s refusal to take the stand weakened her claims, the state said, asserting that the court has jurisdiction to try her on fraud and corruption charges linked to the allegedly irregular tender awarded during Magashule’s tenure.
The main trial resumes Wednesday, pending Judge Loubser’s ruling. The outcome could impact proceedings against Magashule and other co-accused in one of South Africa’s most high-profile graft cases.